In this post, we analyze a legal concept that is growing in importance over the years and that offers citizens an increasingly common option in the legal framework of their romantic relationships: a middle ground between the legal absence of a relationship resulting from inaction, and the extensive rights and obligations of traditional marriage. We are discussing the legal status of unmarried couples , and we will examine its general aspects, comparing them with the legal framework for marriage in Spain.
What are the couples in fact
In Andalusia, the regulations governing the legal status of de facto couples are limited to Law 5/2002 of December 16 on de facto couples , defining this institution as "the union of two people, regardless of their sexual orientation, in order to live together in a stable manner, in a relationship of affection analogous to that of a married couple ," with the only exceptions being minors, relatives of each other, and people who have any type of existing marital bond.
Procedure to obtain effects
As a civil contract, the procedure to obtain the registration of a de facto couple in the Administration and be able to enjoy all its effects requires two main and distinct aspects : the first, documents that prove that the couple meets all the legal requirements to be registered (as we mentioned earlier: legal age, not being involved in another marriage or de facto couple, and absence of kinship); the second, an express declaration of will from both contracting parties in which they state their intention to legally register as a de facto couple.
Effects and differences with ordinary marriage
From a general perspective , the main difference lies in the fact that, unlike traditional marriage, there are no strict, cohabiting couples who must adhere to a set of rules. This allows couples who choose this option greater flexibility in all matters governing their relationship. They can use written and registered agreements that, while respecting the law, morality, and public order, will regulate aspects such as financial arrangements, contributions to household expenses, alimony, and financial compensation upon dissolution of the relationship.
Within the field of family law , the main differences that can be noted between the regulation of one institution and the other are summarized in those relating to national adoption and inheritance upon the death of one of the cohabitants.
- With respect to adoption it must be commented that this is a rather controversial topic and with many loopholes and legal contradictions between state and regional regulations. Law 5/2002 of Andalusia does not clarify anything in this regard: it establishes the possibility of unmarried couples to obtain permanent foster care, but does not regulate or refer at any time to what happens with adoption, so we can understand that at least in the Andalusian area this not allowed outside the marriage bond.
- With respect to The heritage and contrary to what happens in the marriage institution, the Andalusian regulations only grant the deceased's partner the reside in the habitual residence for a maximum period of one year. With the exception of this point, the inheritance regime of the Civil Code will benefit with the inheritance to the children of the deceased in the first place, and to their parents in their absence, always excluding the position of the non-marital partner. The solution to this problem: create a will in which this circumstance is corrected.
In the other branches of law, we find the following as more differentiating and damaging aspects for unmarried couples:
- Contrary to what happens within marriage, the civil status of the unmarried partner is not modified, keeping the previous one to the registration of the relationship in the Registry.
- La widow's pension It will be obtained only when the surviving person proves a stable and notorious coexistence of five years and only in cases in which in the calendar year prior to death they have obtained a percentage of income lower than that of the deceased couple.
- It will be impossible to present the statement of income jointly, excluding the possibility of obtaining the benefits derived from it.
- Some damage will also be obtained in relation to deductions for sale of real estate. The couple that has decided to sell their habitual residence in a period prior to three years after their purchase, will not have to return the deductions that have been self-assessed in each statement; couples in fact do have to.
Dissolution
With regard to this matter, there are no significant differences between de facto couples and the ordinary marriage regime, with Law 5/2002 establishing the following possible grounds for dissolution :
a) Death or declaration of death of any of its members.
b) Marriage of the couple or one of its members.
c) Mutual agreement.
d) Unilateral will of one of its members.
e) Effective cessation of coexistence for a period of more than one year.
The effects of such dissolution will be those that correspond according to the agreements formalized between the members of the de facto couple, so that only in the event that the interests of a minor are in danger or when there is nothing agreed or arranged will it be necessary for a judge to mediate and decide between the wills of the members of the couple.
Conclusion
In summary, and if the question is which regime is the ideal one, it is answered correctly arguing that there is no such one for all circumstances and that each one has its advantages and disadvantages. In fact, couples show a lot of flexibility when it comes to personalizing the rules by which the personal relationship is to be governed, and married people pay their greatest rigidity and predisposition to general rules with certain fiscal and social advantages that, not yet very Important, they can be helpful on certain occasions.
Concluding, it will be necessary to resort to the specific case and above all to the will of the couple to determine what it is that they want and, accordingly, to estimate one way or another.
Álvarez Ramos Lawyers
More information: family law attorneys