Lately, it's not uncommon to find a flood of news about current banking issues and their legal consequences. On this blog, we've already discussed other abusive clauses, such as mortgage floor clauses or those linked to the IRPH ( Mortgage Reference Index) or multi-currency mortgages . Today, we're going to talk about the early repayment clause.
What is an early expiration clause?
The early maturity clause is a condition that has been appearing in practically all mortgage contracts in the last decade. This allows the bank to give up the entire loan before the agreed term for its repayment, in those cases in which the debtor does not fulfill his payment obligation.
In other words, it is that clause that enables the bank to give up the entire debt and start a foreclosure procedure (with the consequent launch of our home) if we stop paying the monthly installments or part of them.
As a general rule, we can find this clause in point 6 (bis) of the deeds of our mortgage loans and its wording is usually similar to the following:
“… Notwithstanding the agreed term, its anticipated maturity will occur, with the correlative power of the financial institution to demand, with foreclosure, how much is owed for principal and accessories, if the borrowing party does not pay on time and exactly as agreed the interests and the global installments of amortization and interests, or the partial non-payment of a single installment ”.
Legal basis
The early termination clause that we know derives its legal basis from the Civil Code :
Article 1124.
The power to resolve the obligations is understood implicit in the reciprocal, in the event that one of the obligated parties does not comply with what is incumbent on him.
The injured party may choose between demanding compliance or resolution of the obligation, with compensation for damages and payment of interest in both cases. You can also request the resolution, even after having opted for compliance, when it proves impossible.
Article 1.255.
The contracting parties can establish the covenants, clauses and conditions that they consider convenient, as long as they are not contrary to the laws, morality or public order.
It is the Civil Procedure Law itself , in its article 693.2, that empowers to " claim the total amount owed for capital and interest if the total maturity has been agreed upon in case of non-payment of at least three monthly installments without the debtor fulfilling his payment obligation or a number of installments such that it implies that the debtor has failed to fulfill his obligation for a period, at least, equivalent to three months and this agreement is recorded in the deed of constitution and in the respective entry."
What do the Courts think about the early maturity clause?
In March 2013, the Court of Justice of the European Union declared that Spanish regulations were contrary to European law regarding mortgage enforcement , given that the existence of abusive clauses in mortgage loan contracts was not among the grounds for opposing the enforcement procedure.
Given the aforementioned situation, the Government amended the Civil Procedure Law , modifying articles 693.2 (the breach necessary to terminate the mortgage loan is increased from one to three) and 695 to allow opposition to the mortgage enforcement procedure for a series of reasons, including the abusive nature of a contractual clause.
The CJEU in Judgment of March 14, 2013, established, with respect to the early maturity clause, the essential criteria that allowed the national judge to decide whether a breach was serious, thus appreciating the abusive nature of said clause:
- if the consumer breaches an essential obligation of the contract.
- if the default is serious in relation to the amount of the loan and its relation to its duration.
- if the power to terminate the contract is exceptional for the creditor.
- If national law provides, it has adequate and effective means for the consumer to remedy the effects of the early maturity of the loan.
In this way, we must weigh not only the percentage of unpaid debt but also the instruments that the financial institution could have to claim the debt.
In other words, the early termination clause that gives rise to a mortgage foreclosure procedure when a single deadline , or even several (always in relation to the total and the duration thereof), is breached is abusive.
New consultation to Europe
We are currently awaiting a new resolution by the European Court of some questions that were raised by the Supreme Court regarding the early maturity clause, which understands that, on certain occasions it may be more beneficial for the consumer to continue with the foreclosure procedure to dismiss it.
However, everything seems to indicate that the Court of Justice of the European Union will confirm the line that it already advanced in 2016, where it came to say that it could not be more beneficial for the consumer to continue with a foreclosure procedure than to proceed with its dismissal. .
Conclusion
The mortgage loan deeds are extremely complex, since any clause can do enormous harm to the requesting party. Therefore, from this law firm we advise you, before signing anything, to go to a specialized professional who can advise you on the drafting of the document and its legality.
