The disease known as COVID-19 or Coronavirus is attacking the world economy and, perhaps more importantly, the Spanish one. They are "only" a few months of hiatus, but it is enough to end the life of much of the industrial and business fabric of Spain. Therefore, one of the most important consequences of this crisis is, unfortunately, the increase in bankruptcy proceedings for both companies and the self-employed. In this article we are going to try to clear the most important doubts related to the bankruptcy and the Coronavirus.
The bankruptcy: basic concepts.
Before going into detail, it's always important to understand some basic concepts of what insolvency proceedings entail under ordinary circumstances. As this firm has extensive experience with these types of proceedings, we have published several articles on the subject, and we offer the most relevant ones below:
This article discusses when it is necessary to file for bankruptcy and the advantages and consequences of doing so immediately versus waiting. The obligation to file for bankruptcy.
Once insolvency proceedings have been declared, this article will serve to classify the debts held according to the types established by the Insolvency Law, each with its own specific effects. Classification of debts in insolvency proceedings.
Here we're talking about a little-known but extremely important figure (perhaps the most important, even more so than the judge) in insolvency proceedings: the insolvency administrator and their functions.
We conclude the insolvency proceedings with the agreement phase (which we haven't yet covered) or the more well-known liquidation phase, which we discuss in this article. The liquidation phase in insolvency proceedings.
And as an appendix for individuals or self-employed business owners , we include in this article a few words about the so-called Second Chance Law. Analysis of the Second Chance Law.
How coronavirus affects bankruptcy.
Having learned the basics for an ordinary bankruptcy situation, we explain below how this health and economic crisis affects the ordinary bankruptcy legislation. As of the writing of this article, the differences are not very important in number, but in content. We find two main changes:
The first change relates to the obligation to file for insolvency proceedings, which we discussed in the first article we referenced. Royal Decree-Law 8/2020, of March 17, on urgent extraordinary measures to address the economic and social impact of COVID-19 , in its article 43, makes several important modifications in this regard:
- Companies that are insolvent they have no obligation to declare bankruptcy while the alarm state lasts. This means that the period of two months that would ordinarily be had is suspended, and the entrepreneur can rest easy because that time passes without having declared the contest.
- El two month term It will start counting once the alarm state ends, and in this case the employer should not pass this period if he does not want to have future problems with the contest.
- necessary competition requests (that is, those made by creditors and not by the bankrupt company itself) will not be accepted until the previous two-month period has ended. More peace of mind for the businessman, who knows that he will be able to apply for bankruptcy on the last day of his term without any creditor going ahead, harming him with a necessary bankruptcy.
- Lastly, the debtor who is not insolvent but has no obligation to declare bankruptcy have started the procedures to start the competition procedure. As those who have declared pre-bankruptcy, or who have initiated an extrajudicial payment agreement file (important for those who carry out the second chance law), etc.
The second change naturally relates to the possibility for the company to use the current crisis as an excuse to obtain a classification of the bankruptcy proceedings as fortuitous rather than culpable . It's important to remember that this difference is significant, since in the case of culpable bankruptcy, the company's debts are transferred to the personal assets of the administrator.
Judges and insolvency administrators will generally need to be more lenient when classifying insolvency proceedings as unforeseen. We expect the courts' approach to be roughly as follows: if the insolvency proceeding is related in any way to how the Coronavirus has affected Spanish companies, it should, in principle, always be classified as unforeseen. This excludes , of course, cases involving any of the circumstances of culpability stipulated in Articles 164 and 165 of the Insolvency Law , or other particularly malicious acts or those resulting from gross bad faith or negligence on the part of the business owner.
