Differences between guardianship and conservatorship

differences between conservatorship and conservatorship
Share this post:

In the Spanish Civil Code, there are two main ways to limit a person's legal capacity: guardianship and curatorship. Both are implemented with the best interests of the person whose capacity is limited in mind and must be processed and declared by a judge. However, there are some key differences between them that distinguish them and are quite relevant. This article will analyze these differences from a practical perspective.

Main difference: total limitation vs partial capacity limitation.

When discussing guardianship , it's important to understand that the guardian not only advises and assists the ward in their legal matters, but also has the right and the obligation to represent them, always acting in their best interests. Thus, the guardian is required to manage the ward's assets with due diligence, and the ward cannot undertake any significant legal transaction without the guardian's signature. Procedures such as submitting applications or appeals to government agencies, buying or selling valuable assets, accepting or renouncing inheritances, initiating legal proceedings, or transferring funds between bank accounts are just a few examples where the guardian's participation and representation are mandatory.

In guardianship , however, the limitations on the ward's capabilities (and the guardian's power) are much less pronounced. It is difficult to provide general examples, since in these cases it is the judge who, through their ruling, establishes the limits according to each specific case. However, generally, the most significant financial transactions will be restricted (for example, purchases and sales of real estate or other high-value assets, large money transfers, investments in financial products, etc.), while the ward will be allowed to freely carry out all other transactions they wish.

Cases in which guardianship proceeds and in which guardianship proceeds.

The main reason for choosing one legal system over another depends primarily on the nature and circumstances of the person whose legal capacity is being restricted. In serious cases , where the person with limited capacity is practically unable to care for themselves, guardianship should be used. For all other cases, curatorship is appropriate.

Thus, according to Article 276 of the Civil Code, the individuals for whom guardianship can be applied are either minors who are not yet of legal age but are emancipated from their parents, or those declared spendthrifts. The first case involves individuals who, although not yet eighteen years old but over sixteen, demonstrate a level of maturity and emancipation inappropriate for their age . These young people are usually limited in terms of the most important transactions they can undertake (for example, acquiring real estate with a mortgage), but are generally allowed to have virtually full legal capacity. The second case involves those declared spendthrifts , who are individuals who, despite being otherwise normal, demonstrate an inability to manage their assets properly, whether due to large-scale extravagance, gambling problems, or other factors. The law allows the spouse and descendants or ascendants of the spendthrift the possibility of judicially initiating this regime, obtaining a guardianship in which the judge will prevent the affected person from accessing large sums of money but preserving the rest of their capacity to act.

So, what are the cases in which guardianship is appropriate ? Generally speaking, it applies in practically all other cases where it is necessary to limit a person's legal capacity. Specifically, Article 222 of the Civil Code outlines these two main possibilities: unemancipated minors and those legally incapacitated . The first case is so straightforward that it doesn't require much explanation: all minors under eighteen years of age are subject to the guardianship of their parents or legal guardians. The second case applies to those individuals who, primarily due to mental illness, lack sufficient capacity to act in legal matters. For them, it will be necessary to appoint a guardian who, representing the interests of the affected person, can carry out actions on their behalf without undue difficulty.

Comments

Leave your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

*