After a turbulent process, the Spanish Congress of Deputies approved the draft reform of the Intellectual Property Law this Thursday with 172 votes in favor, 144 against, and 3 abstentions. This legislation has been the subject of significant debate since its inception, not only on social media but also in the courts. Therefore, we believe it is essential to provide an in-depth analysis, not so much from a moral, ethical, or opinion-based perspective—about which a vast amount of information is already available—but rather from a strictly legal and objective standpoint.
Regulations for the reform of the Intellectual Property Law
The draft bill to reform the Intellectual Property Law has been primarily recognized for its role in developing the so-called "AEDE Levy" or " Google Tax ," but the regulatory changes have been far more significant and have affected a wider range of matters related to Intellectual Property. In this post, we will examine these perhaps less publicized but equally important modifications , and in subsequent articles, we will address the entire issue concerning the tax imposed on online links.
1st modification. Extension of the concept of “offender”.
Article 158 ter – concerning the concept of infringer – is amended by removing the phrase “in a significant manner .” The difference is not insignificant, since with the new wording any website owner who infringes an intellectual property right in any way can be sued and convicted for said infringement, however minor or small it may be.
The procedure for restoring legality will be directed against information society service providers that significantly infringe intellectual property rights…
The literal interpretation of the same precept continues with all this new content, which significantly affects those "facilitators" of links who act in a non-neutral way, that is, who carry out an activity of maintenance, supervision or updating of the same.
... including those made available or provided by any means, in a non-neutral way, through any link or redirect, works or services, violating intellectual property rights, provided that said providers, directly or indirectly, have caused or are susceptible of causing property damage.
This content is designed to include in the regulations all websites that, while not directly infringing intellectual property rights, contain links within their content that affect those same rights . As an example, we can recall the landmark ruling of July 22nd of this year , in which the National Court determined that portals that merely facilitate links did not, according to the previous wording, infringe any intellectual property rights. With the new wording, the solution will be precisely the opposite.
2nd modification. Need for notification.
According to the reform of the Intellectual Property Law, anyone wishing to initiate sanction proceedings against an alleged infringer must prove that, prior to filing the complaint, they unsuccessfully requested the removal of the content from said individual. It will be necessary to prove that the notification was sent, but not whether it was received by the accused; therefore, any physical document or email sent to them—whether or not it was received—will be sufficient to begin the sanction proceedings.
3rd modification. Preliminary investigative proceedings against the alleged offender.
In certain cases, one of the biggest problems when bringing intellectual property infringers to court is identifying the individuals involved, since if their identity is unknown, the complaint cannot be filed against anyone. To overcome this significant obstacle, a preliminary procedure has been created which, when submitted to the courts, will allow the administration to judicially identify an individual for whom there is "reasonable evidence" of infringement.
At first, such serious diligence - this is to obtain the forced identification of someone whose illegality has not yet been proven - was limited to content dissemination "on a large scale", but with the latest reform eliminates this restriction, so that it ends up expanding to any active user who may have allegedly committed a legal infringement related to Intellectual Property rights.
3rd modification. The Second Section of the Intellectual Property Commission comes into play.
Once the procedure is opened ex officio by complaint from any interested party or from the administration itself, the Second Section decides whether to admit the claims for processing or not, and also decides whether an infringement has been committed or not in each of the admitted cases.
This last point is a very important modification, as it transfers this power from the judicial bodies —as was the case in the previous wording—to a body entirely linked to the Administration. To this end, it is worth recalling that the aforementioned Second Section is composed of the Secretary of State for Culture as president, two members from the Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport, one member from the Ministry of Industry, one member from the Ministry of Justice, one member from the Ministry of Economy, and one member from the Ministry of the Presidency.
4th modification. Voluntary withdrawal of content.
This measure, contained in the previous regulations and annulled by the Supreme Court, has now been elevated to the status of law , acquiring much greater legal effect and avoiding potential oversight by courts other than the Constitutional Court. Its literal wording is as follows:
The interruption of the provision of the service or the voluntary withdrawal of the unauthorized works and services will have the value of implicit recognition of the aforementioned violation of intellectual property rights and will end the procedure.
The Second Section has the power to require the removal of content from any individual it deems to be infringing intellectual property regulations. If the alleged infringing individual complies with such a request, they will be implicitly acknowledging that they have committed an illegal act and may therefore be ordered to pay the fines or financial damages resulting from said act.
5th modification. Sanctions.
If the answer is the opposite and the subject refuses to remove content that is later declared to infringe intellectual property rules, the responsible party will have to face fines with a maximum limit of 600.000 euros , exactly double what was contained in the previous wording.
Along with this and as a new element, the Second Section will be allowed to compel companies and people with whom the offending subject has intermediary relationships, electronic payments or advertising, to suspend their services to said subject until the withdrawal of the guilty contents.
Conclusion
These are the most significant modifications to the reform of the Intellectual Property Law, encompassing many generally restrictive changes to legislation that already severely limits rights and falls short of most European regulations. Ultimately, it will be up to the Constitutional Court to issue a reasoned ruling on whether this limitation of rights is sufficiently burdensome to warrant the annulment of certain provisions. Until this ruling is issued, and should it ultimately be so, this will be the legal reality for active internet users, and they will have to act and participate in the enjoyment of its services accordingly.
Álvarez Ramos Lawyers
More information: intellectual property lawyers