News about the return of floor clauses

Share this post:

In April 2015, we wrote an article about the refund of mortgage floor clauses, expressing our opinion on the matter following the landmark Supreme Court ruling of March 25th of that year. Now, more than two years later, with many developments in the interim, we feel compelled to write a new article, in which we reiterate our current stance on mortgage floor clauses.

Royal Decree Law 1-2017 and its consequences.

In January 2017, as most readers will know, the Government enacted a Royal Decree that significantly altered the situation regarding mortgage floor clauses, although many felt it did not go far enough. The Royal Decree, in theory, obliges banks and savings banks to offer a mechanism for customers to claim refunds and requires them to send a response to each claimant within a maximum of three months , whether the claim is accepted or denied.

In practice, the situation has largely followed the guidelines established in this regulation. Most entities have complied with the obligation to provide their clients with the necessary documents for filing claims (some better than others, it must be said), and some have amicably refunded the requested amounts . Therefore, three scenarios arise depending on the client:

Customers who haven't yet filed a claim must do so, one way or another, sooner or later. They can continue waiting, and perhaps in a few years the matter will be resolved differently (or the lender might even contact the customer, as has happened in a small percentage of cases), but most likely, if the customer doesn't take action, the matter won't either. There's also no need to worry too much about the statute of limitations expiring, as it only begins to run from the moment mortgage payments cease.

Customers who have filed a claim and received a bank offer of compensation have every right to suspect that the amounts the bank quoted may not be what they are actually owed , and therefore, doubts about these amounts are common. Resolving these doubts is quite simple: perform the calculations yourself (if you have some knowledge of the matter) or consult an economist or lawyer who can do so. You can also use online calculators, but always keep in mind that the results from these tools are usually approximate.

Customers who have filed a claim and received a negative response from the bank have, unfortunately, only one option: to go to court to exercise their rights. While not all cases have a high probability of success, the vast majority do. Consulting a legal professional will determine whether you fall into the first or second group.

What to do to get the return of the floor clause in the normal case

By normal case we understand all those that are not within those that we will express in the following section. And for these normal cases, luckily, the situation is easy to explain. It begins first with a burofax or similar claim that works in order to comply with the provisions of the Royal Decree and the corresponding three months are expected.

If the financial institution is willing to negotiate and offers a refund amount, it is reviewed and verified to ensure its validity. Otherwise, legal action is pursued. Based on the rulings issued daily, it can be said that most standard mortgage floor clause cases have a good chance of success , but one should never assume victory because the financial institution will also present its arguments, which can be very compelling.

Cases excluded from return of floor clauses

There are indeed some clients for whom, barring any surprises, the situation is considerably more complicated than in typical cases . This doesn't mean the cases are lost, but it does mean that one cannot go to court with the certainty that the case is "practically won." Depending on the specific circumstances, it will be necessary to assess whether there are good chances, some chances, or no chance at all of obtaining a favorable ruling. Generally speaking, these are the possibilities, although there may be many more and different ones.

Cases where a prior agreement was reached with the lender, and said agreement includes the waiver of any right to make future claims. It remains to be seen whether such agreements are legal, but what is clear is that when most consumers signed them, they were fully aware of what a mortgage floor clause was and how it was affecting their mortgages. Convincing judges otherwise (as is done in normal cases) will be impossible, so the strategy will have to be different. Unless there are signs of abusive clauses in the second agreement as well, these types of cases will be difficult to pursue.

Cases where the mortgage floor clause is part of a mortgage held by a company. These situations vary greatly depending on the specific company, but in principle, while they are considerably more complex than ordinary cases, they can offer a good chance of obtaining a favorable ruling. By "specific company," we simply mean that it's not the same if the owner of the mortgage floor clause is a company in the real estate sector (which is presumed to have a clear understanding of what it is signing) as if it sells basic goods, for example.

Cases where there has already been a ruling on the mortgage floor clause, and it is unfavorable. These types of situations, unless the regulations and jurisprudence change drastically, are difficult to win in ordinary court . It is unfair from the perspective of the affected party that, having received a ruling earlier than expected, they have been penalized with an unfavorable decision that cannot be overturned, but that is how the principle of "res judicata" works in law, for better or for worse. One alternative, yet to be explored, might be to sue the administration for the damages caused, but for now it is a rather experimental possibility.

Conclusion

After more than four years have passed since the sentence that uncovered the whole issue of the floor clauses, the topic is still in fashion within the branch of law. Many are still affected, judgments continue to appear, and there are still financial entities that, contrary to the Supreme Court, the Court of Justice of the European Union and a Royal Decree expressly created for this purpose, consider that its floor clauses are completely legal and therefore valid. For these cases, only two solutions are contemplated: either keep waiting or decide to definitively claim the amounts. Both are correct, as long as the subject is never left out.

Álvarez Ramos Lawyers

More information: lawyers specializing in mortgage floor clauses

Comments

Leave your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

*